← Back to TIL

newton’s experimentum crucis

Jan 22, 2026

physicshistorysciencenewton

the context

before newton, many thought prisms created color. white light went in, glass did something, colors came out.

newton didn’t buy it, so he escalated.

experiment 1: single prism

white sunlight → prism → spectrum.

expected result. shows dispersion exists, but doesn’t yet kill the “glass modifies light” theory.

experiment 2: isolation test

single prism again, but now newton isolates one color (via aperture) and refracts it again.

result:

  • red stays red
  • blue stays blue

this strongly suggests colors are intrinsic, but skeptics could still wiggle.

experiment 3: the experimentum crucis

this is the crucial one.

  • prism 1: white light → spectrum
  • lens: recombine the spectrum back into white light
  • prism 2: refract the recombined light again

result:

  • the spectrum reappears exactly as before

boom.

if prisms created color, recombination should have “reset” things. instead, recombined white light behaves identically to original sunlight.

what this proves

  • white light is a mixture of colors
  • prisms only separate and recombine
  • color is not added, distorted, or manufactured by glass